PrintEmail
Comment
A Great Debate: To Detox or Not
Posted by Marisa Belger on March 14, 2006 - 7:14pm.
files/images/prod/1127/1detoxfruit.gif

To detox or not to detox? For those seeking more energy, easier digestion, and improved health, this is undoubtedly the question. Actively triggering a detoxifying reaction in the body through fasting, dramatic dietary changes, or supplements, is a revered method of rejuvenation to some and a clumsy interference with nature to others. Below we look at both sides of the debate.

The Pros

Embarking on one of the many detoxification regimens available today — which can be as simple as eating more vegetables and less meat or as bold as consuming nothing but water and lemon juice — is considered by certain segments of the population to be an effective method of relieving the body from the daily strain of normal eating and drinking.

Detox advocates believe that cleansing in this way not only gives the digestive system a necessary tune-up, but also increases energy and treats many ailments from headaches and bad breath to skin problems and allergies.

The Cons

The primary stance of the anti-detox community is that the body is designed to detoxify naturally. "Healthy adults, even overweight adults, have been endowed with extraordinary systems for the elimination of waste and regulation of body chemistry.

Our lungs, kidneys, liver, gastrointestinal tract, and immune system are effective in removing or neutralizing toxic substances within hours of consumption,” explained Roger Clemens, professor of molecular pharmacology and toxicology at the University of Southern California and Dr. Peter Pressman, an endocrinologist at private medical firm, in a BBC report. The positive results experienced by many detoxers may be due to nothing more than having made a healthy shift in their diets.

"There are thousands of testimonials that describe experience of less bloating (actually the result of eating less food), clearer skin (improved hydration) and decreased headaches (reduced alcohol and caffeine),” Clemens and Pressman said. 

The Truth

Adding to the detox debate is the issue of weight. Many people use detoxing as a quick slimming solution. People like my mother. She just completed six days of The Master Cleanser. The pro-detox camp connects weight loss to the natural process of detoxification, while those who are anti-detox — primarily the allopathic medical community — express concerns about losing weight in such a dramatic and quick manner. There is one thing both sides can agree on: detoxing is tough. Elanor Taylor summarizes this concept in “Sin, Salvation and Celery Juice," an article written for the Social Issues Research Center. “There is a kind of puritanical zeal about the detoxing process, reminiscent of monks fasting or flagellating themselves for their sins. Which of course is not to be condemned, but is hardly the basis of balanced, empirically tested nutritional advice,” she writes. Which argument makes the most sense to you? Have you personally tried any detoxification methods? If so, how did it feel? Did it work? Let us know in our Comments section below.

 

Image: godsherbs.com



Related Shop Items


<em>Humberto</em>'s picture
Me gusta mucho la papaya!!!
by Humberto on March 15, 2006 - 4:36am

<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Detox
by Anonymous on March 15, 2006 - 2:04pm
Any kind of extremity is not good for Atom, Molecule, Earth, Solar System, Universe or Cosmos. Any natural process is acceptable. Rajesh Sharma http://www.rajeshmsharma.blogspot.com
<em>jjackson</em>'s picture
I can believe that.
by jjackson on March 15, 2006 - 3:33pm
I believe what Rajesh says, plus or minus. Moderation in all things, no? To not eat for a few days, or to only eat lemon juice, just sounds a bit unhealthy to me.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
fasting is natural.
by Anonymous on March 15, 2006 - 8:58pm
The body knows how to take care of itself.The body will automatically go into a fasting mode when sick. Detoxifaction is difficult and not for someone who is not very serious about healthy living. Even if the results are only from eating ang health changes, those changes are exactly what more poeple need to be awakened to healthy living. The eating habits of people today are terrible and poison us causing degenerative diseases. For Gods sake at least eat healthy.
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Rajesh Sharma
by Anonymous on April 22, 2006 - 9:53am
Don Chamberline is absolutely correct when he says that "The body knows how to take care of intself. The body will automatically go into a fasting mode when sick" Human body is the most powerful material. Rajesh Sharma http://rajeshmsharma.blogspot.com
<em>Anonymous</em>'s picture
Detoxing tough? - Think again...
by Anonymous on August 28, 2006 - 9:44am
While it is true that fasting can be difficult at times and may therefore not be everyones choice, a new method for detoxing, based on a non-chemical, non-invasive process (so called 'ionic detox') has become available that is as comfortable as it is effective: just place your feet for 30 minutes or so in a warm footbath - and enjoy... no starvation, no sweating, no taking of laxatives. The treatment is safe and testimonials about its benefits abound. For more information, log on to www.tox-x.com
<em>Sawyer</em>'s picture
I detox for my constipation
by Sawyer on September 7, 2007 - 10:11pm

I would never think of using a colon cleanser for quick weightloss. My beleifs are that one should have a good diet that is well balanced and filled with fruits & vegetables. But I can also see some of the benefits use a cleanser to help keep you regulated and toxin-free. I will do a colon cleansing twice a year, and I think it does help.

But I'm no expert, I would also recommend that you check with your doctor before ingesting a concotion of herbs.


User login


Join Lime Now, it's free

Meet New People

Micaela Devaney (View Profile)

Interests: Anything with an ING: dancing, biking, listening, talking, writing, reading, watching, eating, drinking, running, thinking, working, dreaming, surrendering, laughing, smiling, acting, traveling, singing, surfing, driving, shopping, thanking, observing, welcoming, connecting, loving, learning, sharing, practicing, asking. I love supermarkets in other places, lyrics to songs, seeking out gluten free food, responding to questions and surveys, finding deals and bargains, doing public relations for anyone/anything I believe in, good conversation, sociological observation, the beach, early mornings, condiments and spices, vitamins and minerals, alternative medicine, nutrition, holistic health, fitness gum, coffee drinking, gun chewing and sitting in the steam room.
Inspiration: Books: Letters to a Young Poet, Rainer Maria Rilke Music: Linkin Park and The Cure People: My mother and all of those that have come before me that have fought their own battles and didn't give up. Places: Carl Schurz Park, New York, NY Movies: In Search of a Midnight Kiss, Stealing Beauty, Beautiful Girls, When A Man Loves a Woman, In America, Magdelene Sisters, The Notebook, Run Fat Boy Run Things: Causes worth fighting for: Lupus and other auto-immune disorders, Organ Donation and impoverished and at-risk youth.

More new members | Create your profile